Experts provide help with assignments of all academic levels and disciplines.
THE POSITIVE PARTSocial networking Web sites are helping businesses advertise, thus social networking Web sites are benefiting businesses...Advertising,Networking Sites,Social Media,Social Network,Website,World Wide Web,
Computers are perhaps the best innovation in the field of microelectronics that has suited well with the advancement in the brand-new century. T...Computers,Invention,Scientific Inventions,
Jane and Steve have been married for five years. Steve lost his job a year ago and has been unable to find employment since then. Jane is a succ...Case Study,Laughter,
As this is my first internship, I decided to give myself the best opportunity in a 5 star resort & spa hotel to enhance my experience, to de...Hospitality,Internship Experience,
→ Production-centered managers – set rigid work standards, organized asks down to the last detail, prescribed work methods o be followed and clo...Leadership,Leadership And Management,
INTRODUCTIONToday, we are living in a modern age engaged in highly computerized technology where computer devices manifest everywhere aim...Job,Software,World Wide Web,
Ralph has chosen this song as he loves it. It’s a song he’d love to be able to play on guitar. Ralph has stated he loves to play his guitar. How...Care,Guitar,Music,
In tonight’s session we have been learning further about Carl Rogers and his conditions of a successful person- centred therapy. We have been ex...Journal,Psychology,Social Psychology,
In our society, free will is something that is ingrained in our set of beliefs that every citizen of the world should possess. We generally beli...Determinism,Free Will,Society,
The chief object of ports is, of course, bodily exercise. “A sound mind in a sound body” is a well-known saying. The heath of the body is essent...Country,Foreign,
Anna, define the term ‘duty of care’The term ” Duty of care” refers to the obligations and responsibilities. It is a key concept in wor...Abuse,Essay,Human Nature,Risk,Safety,Workers,
Since the beginning of time mankind has found that harmony and togetherness are more beneficial to the entirety of the group than dissonance and...Books,
I have always been interested in art since I was young so it did not take me too much time to decide the general area for my project. Drawing, s...Keyboard,Learning,Music,Piano,The Piano Lesson,
You are watching TV and you see the latest celebrity that pops onto the television screen who is dressed in revealing clothing, which has now be...Advertising,Business,Gender,Human,Marketing,Media,Sex,Sexuality,Society,
1. Analyze the effectiveness of the approach to change taken at VC Brakes. 2. Was Andrew Ryan effective? What could he have done differently? 3....Case Study,
IntroductionWrite an Introduction to the assessor (sometimes this is the last thing you write, although it is the first thing the asses...Education,World Wide Web,
MCDONALD’S CORPORATION:McDonald’s Corporation is the world’s biggest chain of hamburger quick food dining establishments which serves aro...Human Resource Management,
Our world today is a crazy one, in many ways. It is so different to what it used to be. The advancement of technology, coupled with such things ...Hiv Virus,Iraq War,Technology,World,
In Certain cases, never cross your mind that City life is better than village life. However, there are so many advantages and disadvantages in c...City,Country,Village life,
IntroductionIn the next couple of pages the author will firstly discuss the main advantages of the crossroad growing adoption of IFRS, ...Business,Framework,
Only a belief in embodied existence after death is philosophically justifiable. Discuss
1- Christian belief in resurrection- outline Jesus’ resurrection after death- Link to hicks idea of the replica. 3- The only meaningful way to talk about survival after death is to say that souls can be reunited- Peter Geach 5- Characteristics and memories can be changed and falsified- Bernard William Descartes said ‘ My essence consists solely in the fact that I am a thinking thing’.
This, if true, implies that our consciousness is separate from our bodies and so we must be able to exist without said bodies.
This of course would then falsify the statement as disembodied life after death would be possible. Indeed, there are many who dispute this argument and one who would agree with the given statement is Bernard William who claims that characteristics and memories can be falsified. He would argue that because our memories can be lost and altered with certain drugs, accidents and illnesses such as Alzheimer’s; the main part of what makes us- us is the link between our minds and our physical form (our bodies).
In Thessalonians 4, we find a much talked about quote among philosophers; ‘..Since we believe that Jesus died and rose again..through Jesus, God will bring with him those who have died.’
This verse gives us a clear idea that the early Christians believed in full, embodied resurrection. Although it is unclear as to whether or not some would have also agreed with a disembodied afterlife before judgment day and resurrection, many devout Christians only accept the embodied resurrection at the end of days. The verse tells us that at first Jesus’ followers didn’t recognise him, as he had changed somehow but the main message is of fully embodied resurrection. However, due to the complexity of the bible, it is difficult to completely understand whether or not there is a state between death and resurrection and many may feel the argument is far from philosophically justifiable.
There has of course also been a long tradition of belief in disembodied afterlife. The Greek philosophy Plato believed we have separate souls which leave our bodies at death in order to join another. In the Phaedo, he recorded a response from Socrates to a question put forward by Crito; ‘In what fashion are we to bury you?’ Plato’s answer clearly shows his belief in the afterlife. It is important to understand that Plato believed in the soul because he believed innate knowledge must just be memories from previous existences.
Furthermore, Plato was part of the chain of thought that says that everything has an opposite but they are always in a cycle, hot becomes cold for cold to then become hot and living things die just for new life to emerge. Believing in the cycle of opposites makes it clear why Plato would have believed in some kind of disembodied soul. Returning to the question put to Plato mentioned at the start of this argument, we see his response makes his belief in the afterlife clear. ‘He imagines that I am the dead body he will see in a little while… but… when I drink the poison I shall no longer remain with you, but shall go off and depart for some happy state of the blessed…’
On the other hand, however, The philosopher; Peter Geach was a strong believer that any talk of life after death where the soul and body are separate is totally meaningless. Geach described the idea of a separate soul and body as a ‘savage superstition’ and he believed that the genius of Plato and Descartes had given the superstition an undeservedly long lease of life. Geach, along with many other modern philosophers argue that the idea of a separate body and soul has come from misunderstanding of scriptural language. In his book, ‘What do we think with’, Geach wrote ‘thinking is a vital activity of a man, not any part of him, material or immaterial.’
This shows quite clearly Geach believed that a human is a single entity which needs to think, rather than a body and a separate mind which just happens to have consciousness. Geach believed that the only reasonable theory of the soul was the Aristotelian idea that the soul is the form of a living body. Many would say that Geach’s argument is fairly week as there is little evidence to back it up and he seems to be ‘piggy-backing’ off other philosophers, namely; Aristotle. Reincarnation, or rebirth (afterlife in a physical form),are a key feature at the heart of Hindu beliefs. Hinduism teaches that every person has an essential ‘self’ known as an atman. They believe the Atman to be eternal and something which seeks to be united with God.
Hindu’s believe that God manifests himself in the atman if each individual, and through a number of births, deaths and rebirths, the person comes to understand a relationship of the atman with God. Once this realisation of unity is reached, the atman no longer needs to continue in the cycle and so is released (moksha). For the Hindu, physical bodies are nothing more than a container for the atman, the atman which holds the persons nature. This means that after going round the cycle a few times, the atman (or soul) is released from the container and moves on to disembodied life after death. Hinduism is the oldest spiritual tradition in the world and there is evidence that it flourished long before recorded history in India which means that the idea of a separate body and soul could have been the original belief.
Descartes is one of the most famous philosophers and dualists and his belief on life after death was that what makes us, us is our ability to think; our consciousness. His conceivability argument leads us to wonder whether or not we need our bodies at all. The argument was laid out with 3 steps, it begins with the premise that a thinking thing can imagine existing without a body. The argument goes onto say that anything which can be conceived is possible and from this that if X can exist without Y then X and Y aren’t identical. The result of the argument is that a thinking thing is not identical with its body and so, they must be separate.
Descartes most famous quote to sum his arguments up is that ‘I think, therefore, I am’ For Descartes, being able to think about not having a body, but not being able to conceive of not thinking at all means our minds must be separate from our bodies and therefore, if we are to believe in an afterlife then there is no logical reason why our minds would die with our bodies. Many believe this Is a fantastic argument for disembodied life after death as it gets the opposition thinking about not thinking and so leaves them at a blank. I feel that the strongest argument covered in this essay is that put forward at the start and the end.
For many, the fact that we cannot think of our minds not existing is a far stronger argument than that of say, Peter Geach as looking back over past scriptures is just like copying off of someone in a test who has made their answers up, we would just be looking at something which may or may not be true. While I was slightly swayed by the first argument in favour of the given statement, due to its use of past events and a tradition of belief, however in then end, I have maintained my view that it is just as philosophically feasible to think of a disembodied life after death then an embodied one., possibly more so.Date: Oct 10,2021